StudyLab โ€บ Piggy Bank โ€บ A simple first plan

๐Ÿท $500 a month for 5 years: a simple first plan

What I tell beginners, and what 33 years of real S&P 500 history says about it

By Larry ยท 3 November 2026

Friends keep asking me how to start. My answer is always the same: keep it boring. One broad fund, a fixed amount every month, and patience. Before I posted this, I tested my own advice against real market history, and here's what it shows, good and bad.

1. Start with one broad fund

For beginners I suggest VOO, which tracks the S&P 500, the 500 biggest companies in the US. One fund, and you own a small slice of all of them.

If you live in Singapore, two things to know about VOO. It's a US fund, so 30% of every dividend is withheld as US tax. In my test that cost about 0.5% a year. Also, if you pass away with more than US$60,000 in US-listed assets, your family may have to deal with US estate tax. Many Singapore investors use Irish-listed versions of the same index instead, such as CSPX or VUAA on the London Stock Exchange. Inside those funds the US withholding is 15%, the dividends are reinvested for you, and they aren't treated as US assets for estate tax. Their fees are a little higher (0.07% a year against 0.03%). Check which ones your broker offers.

2. The plan: $500 a month for 60 months

The beginner plan Set an auto-buy of $500 on the same day every month for 5 years. That's $30,000 in total. Dividends get reinvested. After that, just hold, and keep going if you can. That's the whole plan.

Monthly is enough. In my test, buying daily, weekly or monthly ended within about 1โ€“2% of each other, and monthly keeps fees tiny. A $500 order buys less than one VOO share, so on Tiger it's charged as a fractional trade: 1% capped at US$1, plus GST, about US$1.09 an order. That's roughly US$65 over the 60 months, about 0.2% of what you put in.

3. If you also keep some cash: have a dip plan

Don't buy the dip at random. If you'd like some money ready for bad days, split the $500:

The plan resets once the market makes a new high. The honest result: it made the bad patches gentler, but over 5 and 10 years it usually ended a bit lower (about 5โ€“7% behind) than putting the full $500 in every month. Use it if the cash helps you sleep and stick with the plan, not to beat the market.

What history says

I tested $500 a month into SPY (it tracks the same index as VOO and has a longer history), with dividends reinvested after the 30% US withholding and after Tiger fees. Cash earns the 3-month US T-bill rate. Real data from 1993 to 2 Nov 2026.

StartFund: after 5 yrsFund: after 10 yrsCash only: 5 / 10 yrsWith dip pot: 5 / 10 yrs
Mar 2000 peak$32.6k$34.8k$31.3k / $35.6k$32.2k / $35.1k
Oct 2007 peak$38.5k$72.9k$30.1k / $30.4k$36.4k / $62.0k
Jan 2008$39.1k$77.2k$30.1k / $30.5k$36.7k / $64.8k
Jan 2015$42.2k$80.1k$31.2k / $35.1k$40.2k / $78.4k
Feb 2020 peak$45.5k$56.6k today$32.9k / โ€“$43.1k / โ€“
Jan 2022 peak$43.6k today (58 months, $29k in)$32.1k today$40.5k today

$30,000 put in over 60 months. "Today" = 2 Nov 2026.

Left: $500 a month from the Oct 2007 peak, fund vs dip-pot split vs T-bills vs money put in. Right: value after 60 months for every start month since 1993. 14.5% of starts ended below the $30k put in, median $39.5k.

My takeaway: $500 a month is a great way to start. Give it at least 5 years, and ideally 10. Don't stop when the market is down, because that's the part that works for you.

Try your own numbers in the Piggy Bank calculator โ†’

โ€” Larry ๐Ÿท

How I invest โ†’

General education only. Not financial advice. This post shares my personal approach and a historical test. It is not a recommendation to buy or sell any fund, and it doesn't consider your objectives, financial situation or needs. I am not a licensed financial adviser. Past performance is not a reliable guide to future results. Fund prices can go down as well as up, and you can lose money. Before investing, consider whether a product suits you, and speak to a licensed financial adviser if you're unsure. Tax points are general and may change. Check your own position.

How I tested it

Daily SPY prices and dividends from Yahoo Finance (Jan 1993โ€“2 Nov 2026). Dividends reinvested after 30% US withholding. Tiger SG fees at today's schedule: about US$1.09 for an order under one share, about US$2.19 for one share or more (older years, when SPY was cheaper). Cash earns the 3-month US T-bill rate (^IRX). Buys are on the same day each month for 60 months, then held. Dip pot: half the pot at โˆ’20% from SPY's all-time high, half of the rest at โˆ’30%, once per fall, reset after a new high. No currency moves (results in US$). Sources: IRS (US estate tax for non-residents), Vanguard research on cost averaging, Tiger Brokers SG fees, Tiger auto-invest FAQ.

StudyLab.sg is an independent project. Piggy Bank is for learning how regular investing and compounding work; it is not a recommendation to buy any fund.
Home  โ€ข  Piggy Bank calculator  โ€ข  Privacy  โ€ข  Terms