Tense Slipping in a Story: Why a Composition Starts in the Past and Ends in the Present
13 November 2026 · by Larry
The composition starts well: Last Saturday, my family went to the beach. The sky was blue and my brother ran into the water. Then, two paragraphs later: Suddenly I see a big wave. I run away and my mother shouts at me. Nothing is misspelled. Every verb is a real verb. The marks still go, because the story began in the past and quietly moved into the present without telling anyone.
This is different from getting a single past tense wrong, such as goed for went. Here the child can write ran and shouted perfectly well. What goes missing is the decision, made once at the start and kept to the end, about when the story is happening. This post gives your child one anchor to hold on to, the three places where the present tense is allowed to stay, and the spots where the slip usually happens.
Why a story drifts into the present
I see three reasons, and they often appear together.
- The exciting part feels like it is happening now. A child who is writing the big wave is picturing the big wave. The picture is in the present, so the verbs follow the picture instead of the plan. It tends to happen at the climax, which is exactly where the marker is paying most attention.
- The writing runs ahead of the checking. Past tense needs a small change in almost every verb. A child writing fast, with a time limit, changes the first few and then stops noticing.
- Speech does not always mark the tense. In many Singapore homes the verb often stays the same and a time word such as yesterday or already does the job instead. A child who talks that way has had less practice in hearing that a verb should change. I am not saying that is the reason for your child; it is worth listening for.
The one anchor: the first verb decides
Teach your child to ask, before writing a single line: when is this story happening? For most school compositions the answer is “it already happened”, which means the past tense. The first story verb the child writes then sets the rule for every story verb that follows, apart from the exceptions below. Many teachers expect the past tense for a story, but check what your child’s own teacher asks for, because the school’s instruction wins.
A useful way to say it to a child: the first verb is the boss. Every other story verb follows the boss.
Where the present tense is allowed to stay
Not every present-tense verb in a past story is a mistake, and a child who is told to “make everything past” will start changing words that were right. There are three places where the present is correct.
- What people say. The words inside speech marks stay as the speaker said them. “I am hungry,” said Ben. The said is past; the am is inside the speech and stays present. (Where the quotation marks and commas go is covered in speech marks in composition.)
- Things that are always true. We learned that the sun rises in the east. The learning was in the past; the fact is still true, so it stays in the present.
- What the writer feels about it now. That was the best day of the holidays, and I still smile when I think about it. The smile is in the present because it is still going on.
A child who understands these three exceptions can keep the rest of the story steady without second-guessing the speech.
Where the slip tends to happen
- Straight after the opening. The first two sentences are careful and the third drifts. Ask your child to check the third verb in particular.
- At the sudden moment. Suddenly, I see… or All of a sudden, the dog runs… The word suddenly feels like it belongs in the present. It does not; Suddenly I saw is the same story, still in the past.
- In a list of actions. I picked up my bag, ran to the gate and open the door. The first two verbs are changed and the last is left behind. Lists of actions are easy to get half right.
- After a piece of speech. A child writes the present inside the speech, which is right, and then forgets to go back to the past outside it.
- In the ending. In the end, we go home and I am very tired. A tired child at the end of the paper is a child whose tenses give way.
The check your child can do in two minutes
When the composition is finished, do this once, with a pencil, before handing it in.
- Circle the first story verb. Write a small P next to it if it is in the past.
- Underline every other verb that tells you what happened. Outside speech marks, each one should be in the past too.
- Any underlined verb that sounds like “now” (see, run, open, go) gets a second look. Say yesterday in front of it. If yesterday I see sounds wrong, the verb needs to change.
The yesterday trick is the one I would keep. It turns a grammar problem into an ear test, and the ear is usually better than the eye.
What helps at home
- Tell the story aloud first, in the past. Ask: “What happened at the beach?” A child who answers in the past tense out loud is more likely to start the page in the past too. If they answer in the present, you have found where the habit starts.
- Read a story and look at the verbs. Choose any story that is told in the past and circle five verbs with your child. Ask whether any of them is a “now” word. Outside the speech, it will not be, and that is what the ear should come to expect.
- Ask for a rewrite of one paragraph only. If the slip is at the climax, take only that paragraph and ask your child to change it back to the past. One paragraph is enough practice, and it feels less like a punishment than rewriting the whole piece.
- Fix one habit at a time. If the habit is drifting, do not correct the spelling, the commas and the verbs in one sitting.
- Do not ban the present tense. A child who is told that the present is wrong will change correct speech and general truths into the past. Teach where it is allowed, using the three places above.
Try it tonight
Ask your child to read each sentence, decide whether the story is in the past, and rewrite the verbs that do not fit. Leave the speech alone.
- Last week my uncle took us to the zoo. We see the lions and my sister laughs.
- Yesterday it rained, so we stay at home and play games.
- The boy opened the box. Suddenly he sees a tiny frog.
- I picked up my bag, ran to the gate and open the door.
- “I am thirsty,” says Mei Ling. She drank all of her water.
- We learned that water boils at a high temperature. We use a pot and wait.
One way to answer: We saw the lions and my sister laughed · we stayed at home and played games · Suddenly he saw a tiny frog · and opened the door · “I am thirsty,” said Mei Ling (the speech itself stays in the present) · We learned that water boils at a high temperature (a fact, so it stays present; the sentence after it, We used a pot and waited, goes back to the past).
A note on how it is marked
How a school marks tense in a composition, and whether a particular piece is expected in the past, is set by the school and the MOE syllabus, which you can check at moe.gov.sg. If your child’s English teacher teaches a particular method, follow that one at home so your child is not given two.
On StudyLab, the free English practice has short grammar questions that include tenses. It does not check a whole piece of writing, so treat it as extra practice on verb forms and not as practice for keeping one tense through a story.
Related reading
The wrong form of a single verb is in goed, eated, teached. The way tenses change when a child reports what someone said is in reported speech, and matching the verb ending to the subject is in he go or he goes. If the real trouble is having no story to tell, start with when a child has nothing to write about. For where a story should break into paragraphs, see paragraphs in a composition.
Quick answers
Why does my child switch from past to present in a story? Usually because the exciting part feels like it is happening now, because writing runs ahead of checking, or because the verb in the home language does not change with time. The first story verb should set the tense for the rest.
Should a composition be in the past tense? For most school stories, children are taught to use the past, but it can differ by teacher and by question, so follow what the school asks.
Is it wrong to use the present tense inside speech marks? No. What a person says stays as they said it: “I am hungry,” said Ben.
What is the quickest check? Put yesterday in front of any verb that tells what happened. If it sounds wrong, the verb should change.
My child has the right verbs but still loses marks. Why? Look at whether the first verb and the last verb are in the same tense. A correct verb in the wrong tense still costs the mark.
Try the free English practice →