Its or It's? Why Children Put an Apostrophe Where It Does Not Belong
10 November 2026 · by Larry
The sentence reads The dog wagged it’s tail. Or the opposite: Its raining, so we stayed home. Either way, the red pen goes to the same two words, and your child looks at you as if you had asked them to pick between two identical twins.
It is one of the most common slips in primary composition, and it has a reason. This post gives your child one question they can ask every time, so they do not have to remember a rule. They only have to listen to the sentence.
Why children get this one wrong
Somewhere around Primary 2 or 3, children learn that an apostrophe plus s shows who something belongs to: the girl’s bag, Ali’s pencil case, the dog’s bowl. It is a good rule and they use it faithfully.
So when they want to say the tail belongs to the dog, and the dog becomes it, they do exactly what they were taught: it plus apostrophe plus s. They are following a rule, just on a word that is an exception. That is why it tends to appear in the weeks right after apostrophes for belonging are taught, and why more reading does not always fix it. The child has already learned the pattern. What they are missing is the one place it stops.
The two words, side by side
- it’s is short for it is or it has. The apostrophe marks the letters that were left out. It’s raining is it is raining. It’s been a long day is it has been a long day.
- its means belonging to it. The dog wagged its tail. The school is proud of its library. The cat licked its paw.
Two different jobs, two different spellings. Only one of them has a missing-letters apostrophe.
The test: say it out loud as two words
This is the whole method. Take the word your child has written and read the sentence again with it is in its place. Then, if that did not work, try it has.
- The dog wagged it is tail. Nonsense. So no apostrophe: its.
- It is raining, so we stayed home. Makes sense. So it needs the apostrophe: it’s raining.
- It has been a long day. Makes sense, so it’s been a long day.
If neither it is nor it has fits, the word is showing belonging and has no apostrophe. Children can do this check in two seconds, in the exam hall, with no one to ask. That matters more than a clever explanation, because a rule that needs thinking time gets skipped when the clock is running.
Why its has no apostrophe, even though it shows belonging
This is the question a sharp child will ask, and it is worth having an answer. The apostrophe-s rule is for nouns: the girl’s bag, the school’s library. It is not a noun. It is a pronoun, and the pronouns that show belonging all work without an apostrophe:
- my bag, mine
- your bag, yours
- his bag, her bag, hers
- our bag, ours
- their bag, theirs
- its tail
Nobody writes her’s or your’s by habit, at least not for long. Its belongs on that list. Put its in a row with his and her and it stops looking like an odd one out. A child who writes hi’s would see at once that something is off. It’s for belonging is the same mistake.
One more thing that catches careful children: there is no such word as its’. If a child is trying to be extra safe by adding an apostrophe after the s, tell them that is not a word at all.
The slip that goes the other way
Some children over-correct. They learn that its has no apostrophe, and then they write Its a sunny day or Its been fun. That is the same two words in the opposite direction, and the same test catches it: It is a sunny day works, so it needs the apostrophe.
If your child keeps doing this after being told the rule, look at how they read their work. Many children do not reread at all, because the sentence “sounds right” to them. Both words sound identical. This is a spelling-by-eye mistake, not a spoken-English one, so the fix is a quick look back, not more grammar.
What helps at home
- Teach the test, not the rule. “Say it is. Does it still make sense?” Most children remember a question better than a paragraph of explanation.
- Ask them to find their own examples. In a storybook or a newspaper, find every its and it’s. For each one, say the sentence with it is and see if the test gives the same answer as the printed word. Children enjoy catching the book out, and the book is almost always right.
- Pair it with the list of belonging words. Write his, hers, ours, yours, theirs, its on a slip of paper and let them see that not one has an apostrophe.
- Mark the slip, not the whole composition. If the composition has six other problems, do not circle every one. Pick this one as the thing to fix tonight. A page covered in red teaches a child to avoid writing.
- Do not fix it for them. Put a small dot in the margin by the line and ask them to find it. Finding the slip themselves, then applying the test, is the practice.
- Keep it short. Five minutes, three or four sentences. One slip, one test.
Try it tonight
Read each sentence and ask your child which word goes in the gap: its or it’s.
- The bird built ___ nest in the tree.
- ___ time to pack your school bag.
- The robot lost ___ battery.
- I think ___ going to rain this afternoon.
- ___ been a long week, but the class has done well.
- The class is proud of ___ garden.
One way to answer: its (belonging to the bird) · it’s (it is time) · its (belonging to the robot) · it’s (it is going to rain) · it’s (it has been a long week) · its (belonging to the class). If five of six come easily, the idea is mostly there. For the one that did not, do not give the answer. Ask them to say the sentence again with it is in the gap and listen.
A note on how it is marked
What a school expects at each level, and how many marks a spelling or grammar slip costs in a composition, is set by the school and the MOE syllabus, which you can check at moe.gov.sg. If your child’s English teacher has a particular way of explaining its and it’s, follow that one at home so the child is not given two methods.
On StudyLab, the free English practice is a place to practise English with short questions. I have not checked it against any school’s own grammar list, so treat it as extra practice, not as a replacement for the work your child is given.
Related reading
The same “sounds identical, spelled differently” trap shows up in their, there and they’re. For the apostrophe that does show belonging on a noun, see apostrophes for belonging. And who, which or whose covers another small word that gets mixed up with its look-alike. A different kind of small slip, in capital letters, is worth a look too.
Quick answers
Is it its or it’s? Say it is or it has in its place. If the sentence still makes sense, write it’s. If it does not, write its.
Why does its not have an apostrophe when it shows belonging? Because it is a pronoun, and belonging pronouns (his, hers, ours, yours, theirs, its) never take an apostrophe. The apostrophe-s rule is for nouns, like the dog’s tail.
Can it’s mean it has? Yes. It’s been raining is short for it has been raining. The test still works: say it has and see if it fits.
Is its’ a word? No. There is no such word as its’.
My child knows the rule but still gets it wrong. Why? Both words sound the same, so the slip is usually in the writing, not the thinking. Ask your child to reread each sentence once, and use the it is test on any its or it’s they find.
Try the free English practice →