I or Me: Why Children Write “Me and My Friend Went to the Canteen”
5 November 2026 · by Larry
Your child writes “Me and my friend went to the canteen at recess”, or “Mum gave Ben and I a snack.” You read it twice. Something is wrong with one of them, perhaps both, and you cannot say which. Worse, the one that sounds posh (Ben and I) is the wrong one.
This is the piece about I and me, and its relatives he and him, she and her, we and us, they and them. Children rarely get these wrong when the word stands alone. Nobody writes “Me went home.” The trouble starts when there are two people in the sentence. The good news is that one quick trick settles almost all of it, and a child can do it silently, in the middle of a test.
Why it goes wrong when there are two of you
With one person, the ear knows the answer: I went, give it to me. With “Ben and ___”, the ear stops being sure, and children fall back on two things they have heard.
- They hear “me and my friend” every day. It is how most people talk, at recess, in the bus and at the hawker centre. Speech bends this rule constantly, so the wrong version sounds normal.
- They have been corrected before. At some point someone said “It is Ben and I, not Ben and me.” The child learns one lesson from it: “I” sounds more correct when another name is in the sentence. So they use I everywhere, including where it is wrong (gave Ben and I). Teachers sometimes call this over-correcting, and plenty of adults do it too.
So there are two opposite mistakes, and a child needs a way to check, not a rule to memorise.
The trick: take the other person out
Cross out the other name and read the sentence again with just the one pronoun.
Me and my friend went to the canteen. → Me went to the canteen. (No. I went.) So: My friend and I went to the canteen.
Mum gave Ben and I a snack. → Mum gave I a snack. (No. me.) So: Mum gave Ben and me a snack.
That is the whole method. The ear that could not decide with two people is perfectly sure with one. Say it to your child as a game: “Knock the friend out and listen.”
Why the trick works: who does it, and who gets it
If your child wants the reason, here it is in plain words.
- I, he, she, we, they are for the person doing the action: I ate. She ran. We left.
- Me, him, her, us, them are for the person the action lands on, or the person who comes after a word like to, for, with or from: Mum called me. Give it to her. Come with us.
Teachers call the first group subject pronouns and the second object pronouns. A child does not need those words to do well. “The doer” and “the one it lands on” is enough.
The same trick covers the whole set, not only I and me:
- Her and me went to the library. Take one out: Her went and me went are both wrong, so it is She and I went to the library.
- The teacher praised Dan and he. Praised he is wrong, so it is Dan and him.
- Us went on the bus. It should be We went on the bus. And when it lands on the pair: The driver waved at Ben and us.
Five slips to listen for
- “Me and” at the start. Me and my cousin played badminton. Take the cousin out: Me played. It should be My cousin and I.
- “Ben and I” after a verb or a small word. Mum gave Ben and I a snack. The prize was for Ben and I. It lands on them, so Ben and me. This is the over-correction.
- “Between you and I”. After between, to, with, for, from, use me: between you and me.
- “Her” or “him” as the doer. Her and Mei Ling are in the choir. It should be She and Mei Ling.
- “Myself” to sound polite. Please see Mrs Tan or myself. Myself is for when I do something to myself (I hurt myself), not a smarter-sounding me. A child who writes Ben and myself has usually been told that me sounds rude. It does not.
Does the other person have to come first?
Children are often taught to write “Ben and I” rather than “I and Ben”. That is a politeness habit: put the other person first. It is not a grammar rule. I and Ben went is grammatically fine, if a bit odd. If a teacher marks it down, it will be on style, not on correctness, so it is worth knowing the habit, and not worth worrying over.
What about when we are speaking?
In casual talk, almost everyone says “Me and my friend went”, and “It’s me” when someone knocks at the door. Nobody is confused and nobody needs correcting at the dinner table. The place this matters is written work: composition, grammar cloze and the rewriting exercises. So work on the writing and leave the talking alone. Pulling your child up on every spoken sentence is the quickest way to make them stop telling you about their day.
What helps at home
Teach “knock the friend out”, and let them do it with a pencil. When you read a piece of writing together, have your child cross out the other name with a finger and read the sentence aloud. They hear the mistake themselves.
Use sentences from their own day. “Who came to the playground with you?” Let them answer in a full sentence: “Jia Wen and I went to the playground,” then, “Mum bought Jia Wen and me ice cream.” Real sentences with real names stick better than a worksheet.
Fix one pattern at a time. If your child writes Me and… at the start and Ben and I in the middle, start with the first one. Over-correcting is harder to shift, so give it a week of its own.
Say the right version yourself, without making a fuss. “Oh, so Ben and you went? Ben and I went…” Children copy what they hear most.
What does not help
- “It is always Ben and I.” This is exactly where the over-correcting comes from. It is only Ben and I when the pair is doing the action.
- Learning the words “subject” and “object” before the trick works. Let the trick come first. Names can come later.
- Using “myself” as the safe option. It is not safe. It is a third mistake.
- Marking every spoken slip. See above.
Try it tonight
Made-up sentences, each with one slip. Ask your child to knock the other person out and listen.
- Me and my brother like to play football at the void deck.
- Auntie gave Sam and I a packet of kueh.
- Her and her sister walked to school together.
- The teacher asked Hui Min and he to carry the books.
- Please sit between Ravi and I.
One way to answer: My brother and I like to play football (Me like is wrong) · gave Sam and me (gave I is wrong) · She and her sister walked (Her walked is wrong) · asked Hui Min and him (asked he is wrong) · between Ravi and me (between I is wrong). If your child’s answer differs, ask them to cross out the other name and read the sentence one more time.
A note on how it is marked
How grammar is tested in a paper is set by the school and the MOE syllabus, which you can check at moe.gov.sg. If the teacher has told you which wording they expect, go by that over anything you read online, this piece included.
An honest note on StudyLab as well: it does not have a practice made only for I and me. The free English practice does include a pronouns topic at Primary 2 (he, she, they, it), and the other grammar topics build the same habit of reading a sentence closely: try the English practice. For the order of topics through primary school, see the English guide by level.
Related reading
Another small word that has to fit its sentence is in who, which or whose. Choosing a word by checking it against the rest of the sentence also comes up in grammar cloze, and the same “test it with the sentence made smaller” habit helps in he go or he goes. When I has to become he or she after someone speaks, see reported speech.
Quick answers
Is it “Ben and I” or “Ben and me”? Take Ben out and see. Ben and I went (because I went), but Mum gave Ben and me a snack (because gave me).
Is “Me and my friend went” wrong? In writing, yes: it should be My friend and I went. In casual speech it is very common.
Is “between you and I” correct? No. After between use me: between you and me.
Can I use “myself” instead of “me”? Only when I do something to myself (I hurt myself), not as a fancier me.
Try the free English practice →