StudyLab › Journal

Although and But Together: Why Children Write “Although It Rained, But We Played”

12 November 2026 · by Larry

The sentence reads Although it was raining, but we still went to the playground. Every word is spelled right, the comma is in, and the idea is good. It still loses the mark, because there are two joining words doing one job: although and but. English wants one of them, not both.

Joining words, which school calls conjunctions, are the small words that glue two ideas into one sentence: and, but, so, because, although, when, if, while. Children use them all the time when they talk. The trouble starts in writing, where the rules are stricter than the ear, and the most common trouble is the double join. This post gives your child one question to ask and the short list of slips that follow from not asking it.

Why children double up

In speech, a child says “Although it was raining, but we still went.” and nobody blinks, because the pause hides it. Written down, the same words show two joiners side by side. The child has learned that although means “even though” and that but means “in contrast”, and since the sentence has a contrast in it, both words feel needed. They are not. Each of them already carries the contrast, so using both is like putting two seat belts on one seat.

The check: one join needs one joiner

Ask your child: how many joining words are doing the job between these two ideas? It should be one.

There are two kinds of joiner, and they sit in different places.

That is the whole fix for the double join. Although it was raining, but we went has used one of each kind. Remove either and the sentence is right: Although it was raining, we went or It was raining, but we went.

The slips, one by one

What the comma does

One pattern is worth knowing, because it explains many red circles. When a front joiner starts the sentence, a comma goes after the first half: Because it was raining, we stayed home. When the same joiner sits in the middle, the comma is usually not needed: We stayed home because it was raining. With the middle joiners and, but, so, a comma before them is normal when each side could stand alone: It was raining, so we stayed home.

If your child’s school teaches the comma rule slightly differently, follow the school. The point at home is that the comma follows the shape of the sentence, not the feeling of a pause.

The two-step check your child can do

When a composition is finished, ask your child to underline every joining word. Then, for each one, ask two things:

Underlining makes the double joins visible at once, because two underlines will be sitting next to each other. A child often spots although … but on their own once it is underlined, without being told.

What helps at home

Try it tonight

Ask your child to fix each sentence by keeping only one joiner, and to say which one they kept and why.

One way to answer: Although he was tired, he finished his homework (or He was tired, but he finished his homework) · Because the bus was late, we missed the start (or The bus was late, so we missed the start) · I like durian, but my sister does not (or Although I like durian, my sister does not) · The shop was closed, so we walked home · I was hungry, so I ate my lunch (eating is what hunger leads to, so but turns it the wrong way) · the last one is only half a sentence: I was thirsty because I forgot my water bottle. If a sentence goes wrong, do not give the answer. Ask your child how many joiners they can see.

A note on how it is marked

How a school marks joining words and commas in a composition, and which joiners a particular level is expected to use, is set by the school and the MOE syllabus, which you can check at moe.gov.sg. If your child’s English teacher teaches a particular method, follow that one at home so your child is not given two.

On StudyLab, the free English practice has short questions in many grammar topics. I have not found a topic made only for joining words, so treat it as extra practice for English in general, not as practice for this one.

Related reading

The commas-instead-of-full-stops slip is covered in run-on sentences. Choosing the right word to join a describing part to a noun is in who, which or whose, and rewriting one sentence into a differently built one is in rewrite the sentence questions. Another case of two words doing one job, two negatives in one idea, is in double negatives: I don’t have no pencil.

Quick answers

Can I say although and but in the same sentence? No. Both mean the idea turns against what you expect, so one is enough. Keep although at the front of the first half, or but in the middle.

Can a sentence start with because? Yes, as long as the sentence goes on to say what happened. Because it was raining, we stayed home is a full sentence. Because it was raining. on its own is not.

Do I use a comma before but? Usually yes, when there is a full sentence on each side: It was late, but we kept going.

Is it wrong to start a sentence with and or but? In primary school writing, most teachers prefer that children join the ideas inside one sentence instead. Follow what your child’s teacher says.

My child uses and for everything. What should we do? Ask for one different joiner per paragraph. Switching one and to so, because or when is enough to start.

Try the free English practice →

Related guide: Singapore primary English, level by level

💬 Join the conversation

Got a question, spotted a mistake, or want something added? Say it here. Comments are read by me before they appear, so it may take a day.

No email needed and none is stored. Your name and message are shown publicly once approved — please don't post anything private, and don't use your child's full name.

StudyLab home  •  More posts  •  Guides